What is the most misdiagnosed mental illness? According to research, it is bipolar disorder. A survey, published in the Journal of Clinical Psychiatry, reported that 69% of people with bipolar disorder were initially misdiagnosed, most commonly as having unipolar depression. 

On average, participants reported seeing four different health professionals before receiving an accurate diagnosis. More than one-third of participants waited ten years or longer for an accurate diagnosis (Hirschfeld et al., 2003). Misdiagnosis can delay the treatment of a correct diagnosis and, in the meantime, an individual can be treated for the wrong condition.

Bipolar disorder is not the only condition that is frequently misdiagnosed. According to the National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH), in 2022, an estimated 59.3 million adults (23.1%) in the United States had a mental illness, and 50.6% of those individuals received treatment. 

This means that 25.5% of those adults with mental illnesses were untreated. If a person receives a mental illness diagnosis and is misdiagnosed and treated for the wrong mental condition, it becomes part of the same problem. 

Let’s discuss what conditions are misdiagnosed the most, the reasons for misdiagnosis, signs that physicians tend to overlook, and the effect of an accurate diagnosis on patients and a practice’s revenue.

What Is the Most Misdiagnosed Mental Illness?

Bipolar disorder is the most researched condition regarding misdiagnosis, and it is usually misdiagnosed as depression. The reason for this is that people tend to seek help only when they experience the lows or the depressive side of the disorder. A physician who only sees the depressive side of a patient will most likely diagnose unipolar or major depression and misdiagnose bipolar disorder.

A widely cited survey found that 69% of people with bipolar disorder were initially misdiagnosed, most often as unipolar depression.

Here is how the most misdiagnosed mental illnesses compare.

Condition Often mistaken for Why it gets missed Signal worth a second look
Bipolar disorder Major depression Patients report lows, not highs Past stretches of little sleep with high energy, depression that returns repeatedly, poor response to antidepressants
Borderline personality disorder Bipolar disorder, depression Mood shifts look similar Mood changes within hours, tied to relationships, with intense fear of abandonment
ADHD Anxiety, depression, bipolar disorder Symptoms overlap; women often present differently Lifelong pattern of disorganization and distraction that started in childhood
PTSD Depression, anxiety, panic disorder Trauma history is not always disclosed Nightmares, startle response, avoiding reminders, symptoms that started after an event
Autism spectrum disorder Social anxiety, ADHD, depression Masking and learned coping, especially in girls and women Lifelong social difficulty, sensory sensitivity, intense routines
Anxiety disorders Medical conditions (heart, thyroid) Physical symptoms come first Racing heart or chest tightness with normal medical workup

Why Do Physicians Miss Mental Illnesses?

It is rarely about a lack of skill. It is usually about the setup.

There is a lot of symptom overlap. Sleep problems and problems focusing are part of depression, anxiety, PTSD and bipolar disorder, for example. One symptom usually doesn’t point to one diagnosis.

Appointments are short. Primary care visits are often 15 minutes. This is usually enough time to address depression and write a prescription, but not always to ask about past highs, trauma, or childhood stuff.

What motivates a patient to seek treatment? Not the manic episodes of a bipolar II patient, because from their perspective, they weren’t problems. Many patients with PTSD will not volunteer that they feel unsafe or are having anxiety attacks, because talking about these episodes brings on the flashbacks and anxiety they wish to avoid.

Multiple co-occurring disorders confuse the picture. Is the depression from the ADHD because of a substance use disorder? In the presence of a comorbid substance use disorder, bipolar disorder is often misdiagnosed.

Medical and psychiatric conditions overlap. A patient taking a stimulant can be mistaken for a patient with ADD/ADHD. Thyroid problems or sleep apnea can mimic conditions such as anxiety and depression.

Bias plays a role. Girls and women with ADHD or autism are often overlooked because the classic picture was built around boys. Cultural background, language, and race can also shape how symptoms are described and interpreted.

Why Major Depressive Disorder Is the Common Wrong Answer

A lot of the conditions in the table above get labeled as Major Depressive Disorder first, simply because low mood is what patients bring to the visit. If the patient hasn’t had an episode of unusual energy and/or an increase in goal-directed activity and/or a period of minimal need for sleep with racing thoughts, you shouldn’t necessarily dismiss the diagnosis, but rather explain the possibilities to the patient and make sure the patient is not manic. One simple extra question can point in a totally different direction for the treatment plan. 

Signs Physicians Often Miss, Condition by Condition

Patients with bipolar disorder often remain undiagnosed for a long time. When people with undiagnosed bipolar disorder do come to medical attention, it is often for depression and for episodes of elevated mood and activity that precede or follow the low periods. These patients may present with symptoms including racing thoughts, pressured speech, and sudden, uncharacteristic, and extreme spending and/or professional or creative productivity. A family history of bipolar disorder may be present.

Borderline personality disorder. In terms of symptoms, it can seem similar to bipolar disorder, with the main difference being the duration. In bipolar disorder, shifts happen on the timescale of days to weeks, while in BPD, shifts happen on the scale of hours to days.

ADHD. In adults, the symptoms of ADHD may not seem like the stereotypical hyperactive child. It may present as repeatedly missing deadlines, constantly losing things, and other generally under-controlled behaviors that may be written off as anxiety. For a true diagnosis of adult ADHD, the symptoms must have been present in childhood.

PTSD. Things like irritability and emotional numbing may lead to diagnoses of depression or anxiety. Sleeping issues and avoidance may lead to diagnoses of depression and may be symptoms of PTSD. A history of trauma may seem like an extreme outlier, but asking a single, gentle, broad question may provide answers.

Autism spectrum disorder. Similar to borderline personality disorder, many adults may have learned to mask their difficulties, appearing to be well-adjusted. Looking into a history of burnout may uncover symptoms of being on the spectrum.

What Does Undiagnosed Mental Illness Look Like?

An undiagnosed mental illness may appear similar to always being tired, being behind at work, drinking too much, and other behaviors that may seem unrelated. Research cited by the NIMH states that about half of all mental illnesses begin by age 14, and 75% begin by age 24, meaning that many of these behaviors begin in adolescence and are unnamed for long periods of time.

What Does a Misdiagnosed Mental Illness Cost?

The biggest cost is clinical. A patient with bipolar disorder who was misdiagnosed and treated for depression will not improve, and may worsen. Someone with ADHD, who was misdiagnosed and treated for anxiety, will continue to be challenged by the real condition. There will be many unproductive and repetitive visits, and many changes in medication.

The financial costs follow. Many visits, evaluations, and treatments charged to a third party add up.

How Diagnosis Accuracy Affects Billing and Coding

This part is often overlooked in clinical content. For every mental health claim, the diagnosis must be documented. If the diagnosis is vague or unclear, or changes over the course of treatment, then it affects billing and coding negatively.

If a diagnosis is first documented as unspecified and is clarified later without a clear explanation, it can look inconsistent and lead to denials and audits.

Claims for mental health services include codes for diagnoses, which are validated by payers for medical necessity. Certain CPT codes such as 90837, 90791, or 90792 require a diagnostic code to validate medical necessity. If a diagnosis is initially documented as unspecified, and it is later clarified, it can appear inconsistent and lead to denials and audits.

Diagnosis Example ICD-10-CM code family Billing risk if documentation is thin
Bipolar disorder F31.x Wrong episode type or severity specifier
Major depressive disorder F32.x / F33.x Missing severity or single versus recurrent
PTSD F43.1x Unspecified code used when acute or chronic could be documented
Borderline personality disorder F60.3 Payer questions on medical necessity for long-term care
ADHD F90.x Type not specified, prior authorization gaps for medication visits
Autism spectrum disorder F84.0 Documentation gaps for testing codes such as 96130

A few patterns show up again and again. Unspecified codes draw more payer attention than specific ones. A diagnosis that changes without clear documentation of why raises questions during review. And prior authorizations tied to one diagnosis can lapse when the diagnosis changes, which interrupts care. Practices that work with mental health billing services tend to catch these issues earlier because someone is reading the claim against the chart before it goes out.

Protecting Your Revenue When Diagnoses Change

Behavioral health practices lose money in small, quiet ways, usually through vague codes and thin notes. Proven Steps to Prevent Revenue Loss start with specific diagnosis coding, written reasons for every change, and a quick prior authorization check whenever a diagnosis shifts. A biller that reads each claim against the chart before it goes out will catch most denials, and they will be easy to fix. 

Keeping Up With Coding Changes for Related Conditions

There is often overlap in the symptoms of patients treated by behavioral health practices and patients treated for certain neurological conditions. Aphasia Billing Updates are a good example, since speech and language evaluations carry their own documentation and authorization rules. 

Review payer bulletins every quarter. Be sure to review payer bulletins at least quarterly, and ensure the diagnosis, visit type, and medical necessity documentation on the chart are aligned with the documentation on each claim prior to it being submitted. 

How Practices Can Reduce Misdiagnosis

Better diagnosis does not require more time per patient as much as it requires a better process.

Use validated screening tools. The PHQ-9 for depression, GAD-7 for anxiety, MDQ for bipolar spectrum symptoms, ASRS for adult ADHD, and PCL-5 for PTSD are all widely used. They do not diagnose anything, but they flag what deserves a longer conversation.

Ask about the past, not just the present. Questions about prior highs, childhood symptoms, trauma, and family history change the picture more than any single current symptom.

Rule out medical causes. A basic medical workup that checks thyroid function, vitamin levels, and medication side effects prevents a long list of wrong turns.

Bring in outside information. A partner, parent, or close friend can often describe patterns the patient does not notice.

Revisit the diagnosis. If a patient is not improving as expected, the diagnosis deserves another look. A change is a sign of careful work, as long as it is documented clearly.

Document the reasoning. Notes that explain why a diagnosis was made or changed protect the patient’s care, support medical necessity, and make claims easier to defend.

Following the Rules That Keep Behavioral Health Claims Paid

Clinical accuracy only gets a claim halfway. Mental Health Medical Billing Rules also decide whether it gets paid. Payers expect a documented diagnosis, a time-based CPT code that matches the session length, and a note showing medical necessity. If a psychotherapy session runs 50 minutes but the claim says 90837, the mismatch invites a denial. Build a quick pre-submission check so the chart and the claim agree.

Getting the Billing Side Right

Although getting the clinical side of behavioral health right is important, ensuring that the documentation and coding are also correct is essential in order to get paid. Outsourcing Mental health billing services bridges this gap and makes a difference in behavioral health practices.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the most misdiagnosed mental illness?

Bipolar disorder is the most consistently cited. In one widely referenced survey, 69% of people with bipolar disorder were misdiagnosed at first, usually with depression, and over one third waited a decade or more for the right diagnosis. Borderline personality disorder, ADHD, PTSD, and autism are also commonly missed.

What are the most misdiagnosed mental illnesses besides bipolar disorder?

Borderline personality disorder is often mistaken for bipolar disorder. ADHD is frequently labeled as anxiety or depression, particularly in women. PTSD is often recorded as depression or anxiety. Autism is commonly missed in girls and adults who have learned to mask their difficulties.

How do I know if I have an undiagnosed mental illness?

Warning signs include symptoms that last more than a few weeks, interfere with work or relationships, keep returning, or do not improve with treatment. Only a qualified clinician can diagnose, so if something feels off, bring a written list of symptoms, when they started, and any family history to your appointment.

Can a misdiagnosed mental illness make symptoms worse?

It can. Treatment that fits one condition may not help another, and in some cases it can make symptoms harder to manage. This is why clinicians are encouraged to revisit a diagnosis when someone is not improving as expected.

How long does it take to get an accurate diagnosis?

It varies widely. In the Hirschfeld survey of people with bipolar disorder, over one-third waited 10 years or more. Other studies report average delays of several years, depending on the condition and the country.

Should I get a second opinion if I think my diagnosis is wrong?

Yes, if your symptoms are not improving or the diagnosis does not match your experience. A second opinion from a psychiatrist or psychologist who does a full history is reasonable and common. Bring your records and be honest about symptoms that feel hard to talk about.

Resources

Diagnostic criteria, screening tools, and coding rules get updated, so check these official sources directly before you update your clinical workflows or billing processes.

Mental Health Statistics and Research

  • National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH): The source for U.S. prevalence data, age-of-onset research, and plain-language guides on bipolar disorder, ADHD, PTSD, and other conditions.
  • SAMHSA: National survey data on mental health and substance use, plus treatment locators and behavioral health program resources.
  • Journal of Clinical Psychiatry: Home of the Hirschfeld et al. (2003) survey on bipolar disorder misdiagnosis cited in this guide.

Diagnosis and Screening Tools

Coding and Billing References

  • CDC ICD-10-CM Resources: Official ICD-10-CM code sets and annual updates for diagnosis codes such as F31.x, F32.x, F33.x, and F43.1x.
  • AMA CPT Resources: Official CPT guidance, including psychotherapy codes like 90791, 90792, and 90837, and psychological testing codes like 96130.
  • CMS Behavioral Health Services: Medicare coverage and billing guidance for mental health services.

Get Customized Billing Quote

Also Read